The minimum efficiencies for HVAC equipment (§5.2.2) and for service hot water heating equipment (§5.2.7) must be used for the applicable equipment in the Standard Design. This includes any part-load efficiencies, if these are specified. These efficiency requirements set the baseline for equipment trade-offs under the WBP method. The actual equipment efficiency of the Proposed Design is then used to calculate the Standard Design.
Since mechanical and service hot-water heating equipment efficiency is a prescriptive requirement, if the equipment is covered by these equipment requirements, the equipment efficiency in the Proposed Design must be equal to or greater than the prescriptive equipment efficiency. If mechanical or service hot water heating equipment falls outside of those listed in the efficiency tables, the standard equipment efficiency shall be equal to the efficiency of the equipment in the Proposed Design. Thus the only
trade-off available for equipment efficiency is to specify higher efficiencies than those called for in the ECBC, which would give electricity consumption savings for the design.
9.4.2.1 Minimum Outdoor Air Rates:
Minimum outdoor air rates shall be identical for both the Standard Design and Proposed Design, except
a) when modeling demand controlled ventilation (DCV) in the Proposed Design (DCV is not required in the Standard Design as per §5.2.1.3)
b) when the Proposed Design has a minimum ventilation flow higher than the minimum required by the applicable code, the Standard Design shall be modeled as per the minimum ventilation rate required by the applicable code and the Proposed Design shall be modeled as per actual design (higher than Standard Design)
9.4.2.2 Fan Schedules
Supply and return fans shall operate continuously whenever the spaces are occupied and shall be cycled to meet heating and cooling loads during unoccupied hours.
9.4.2.3 Fan Power
a) For Systems Types A, B and D,
Pfan = cmh x .51
Where Pfan = Standard Design fan power in watts
cmh = Standard Design supply airflow rate autosized by the simulation software
b) For System Type C
Fan power shall be modeled as per power and efficiency limits specified in
Table 5-11 using a static pressure of 622 Pa or the design static pressure, whichever is higher. The simulation software shall automatically calculate the Standard Design fan power based on the above inputs.
9.4.2.4 Design Airflow Rates
Design airflow rates for the Standard Design shall be sized based on a supply air to room air temperature difference of 11 °C. The Proposed Design airflow rates shall be as per design.
9.4.2.5 Economizers (airside and waterside)
Airside economizers shall be modeled in the Standard Design as per the requirements of §5.3.4.
Exception to §9.4.2.5: Airside economizer shall not be modeled for Standard Design HVAC System Type A.
9.4.2.6 Energy Recovery
Energy recovery shall be modeled in the Standard Design as per the requirements of §5.3.7.
9.4.2.7 Chilled Water Design Supply Temperatures
Chilled water design supply temperature shall be modeled at 6.7° C and return temperature at 1 3 . 3 ° C .
9.4.2.8 Chillers
Only electric chillers shall be modeled in the Standard Design for System C. Chillers shall meet the minimum efficiency requirements indicated in Table 5-1 and Table 5-2. Chillers in the Standard Design shall be selected as per Table 9-3 below:
| Peak Building Cooling Load (kWr) | Chiller Type |
|---|---|
| < 1,055 | 1 Water Cooled Screw Chiller |
| 1,055 to 2,110 | 2 Water Cooled Screw Chillers |
| > 2,110 | 2 Water Cooled Centrifugal Chillers minimum, equally sized such that no Chiller is greater than 2,813 kWr |
Exception to above: Air cooled chillers are allowed to be modeled in the Standard Design if the Proposed Design has air cooled chillers. If the proposed building has a mix of air and water cooled chillers, then the Standard Design shall be modeled with a mix of air and water cooled chillers in the same proportion as in the Proposed Design. However, this exception applies only for minimum ECBC compliance. Air cooled chillers shall not be modeled in the Standard Design when demonstrating compliance with ECBC+ and SuperECBC Building requirements.
9.4.2.9 Chilled Water Pumps
Chilled and condenser water pumps for the Standard Design shall be modeled as per power and efficiency limits specified in Table 5-16.
Standard Design chilled water pumps shall be modeled as primary-secondary with variable secondary flow.
9.4.2.10 Cooling Tower
Standard Design cooling tower shall be modeled as an open circuit axial flow tower with power and efficiency as per Table 5-19. The fans shall be modeled as two speed.
Condenser water design supply temperature shall be 2 9 . 4 ° C or 5 . 6 ° C approach to wet bulb
temperature, whichever is lower, with a design temperature rise of 5 . 6 ° C .
9.4.2.11 Boiler
Standard Design boilers shall be modeled as natural draft boilers and shall use the same fuel as the Proposed Design. Boiler efficiency shall be modeled as per Error! Reference source not found..
9.4.2.12 Hot Water Design Supply Temperatures
Hot water design supply temperature shall be modeled at 82°C and return temperature at 5 4 ° C .
9.4.2.13 Hot Water Pumps
The Standard Design hot water pumps shall be modeled with a minimum efficiency of 70% and a pump power of 300 W/l-s-1.
Standard Design hot water pumps shall be modeled as primary-secondary with variable secondary flow.
9.4.2.14Campus/District Cooling Systems
All district cooling plants shall be assumed to be on grid electricity, unless otherwise specified and supported through pertinent documents. New district plants shall comply with the mandatory requirements of ECBC irrespective of who owns and/or operates the district plant.
Projects may choose either option A or option B given below for modelling campus/district cooling systems.
Option A
The cooling source shall be modeled as purchased chilled water in both the Standard Design and Proposed Design. For the Standard Design, Table 9-2, shall be modified as follows:
a) For System Type C; purchased chilled water shall be modeled as the cooling source.
b) System Types A and B shall be replaced with a two-pipe fan coil system with purchased chilled water as the cooling source.
The chilled water/thermal energy consumption simulated by the software shall be converted to units of kWh and added to the overall building energy consumption. The following conversion factors shall be used to convert chilled water/thermal energy consumption to units of kWh.
1 ton hour = 0.85 kWh
1 MBtu = 1, 0 0 0, 0 0 0 Btu = 2 9 3 kWh
Option B
The Standard Design shall be modeled as per Table 9-2 HVAC Systems Map for Standard Design.
For the Proposed Design, model a virtual onsite chilled water plant with Chiller, Pumps and cooling towers modeled at minimum efficiency levels as per §9.4.2.7 to §9.4.2.10. Airside/low side capacities shall be modeled as per design and the plant capacities shall be auto-sized by the software.
| Automatic Control Device | Daytime occupancy and area <300 m<sup>2</sup> | All Others |
|---|---|---|
| Programmable Timing Control | 10% | 0% |
| Occupancy Sensor | 10% | 10% |
| Occupancy Sensor and Programmable Timing Control | 15% | 10% |
Compliance Thresholds for ECBC compliant, ECBC+ and SuperECBC Buildings
For buildings to qualify as ECBC+ and SuperECBC Buildings, the WBP Method shall be followed for the Standard Design as detailed above. The