Defining HVAC systems for use with whole building simulation programs is complex, and there are many interrelated rules. Some of the rules that govern the description of HVAC SYSTEMS for the ECBC whole building performance method are:
The HVAC System described in the Standard Design should just meet the prescriptive requirements of the ECBC. These requirements are deemed representative of
current standard practice that meets the ECBC.
Where possible, the HVAC System is to be conceptualized as completely as possible on the actual system designed for the Proposed Design. This includes the system type, equipment capacities and efficiencies, controls, ancillary features (such as economizers), etc. The equipment efficiencies may need to be adjusted to meet the needs of the simulation program. While efficiencies may be most accurately specified at the building’s design conditions, most simulation programs require efficiencies to be specified at standard rating conditions, such as those given in ECBC §5.2.2.
Where the entire HVAC System design is not known, as in the case of a shell-and-core design, the unknown parts of the system are assumed to just meet the prescriptive requirements of the ECBC and to be energy neutral. This strategy prevents gamesmanship with the undefined system components. Gamesmanship is the practice of artificially reducing the efficiency of the Standard Design in order to increase the apparent relative efficiency of the Proposed Design4.
Where the complete HVAC System exists, the Proposed Design and Standard Design are based on the existing HVAC system – for example, fit out of an existing speculative building for a tenant. The subject of the building permit is primarily the interior construction and lighting system and does not include the HVAC system because it has already been built and permitted. Both simulation models would also include the existing building envelope.
Where no heating system exists, a default heating system must be assumed and modeled. It should be a simple heating system that burns fossil fuel, sized with sufficient capacity to meet the design
heating loads for the Proposed Design. An identical system (with sizing adjustments) must be assumed for the Standard Design.
The WBP Method is more vulnerable to this sort of misuse, which is why the rules for constructing the Standard Design must be so specific. The WBP modeling rules for part-load efficiency and system sizing are intended to minimize these effects on the trade-off calculations for the other measures in the building. For example, electricity consumption differences cannot be gained for a difference between a properly sized HVAC system in the Proposed Design and an improperly sized HVAC system for the Standard Design. The modeling rules are discussed individually in the following sections:
• Where no cooling system exists, a default cooling system must be assumed and modeled for both the Standard Design and Proposed Design.