15.3.1 Grant of Transfer of Development Rights
Transfer of development rights, or TDR, is a certificate from the relevant planning authority that the owner of a property gets for developing public utilities such as parks, schools and hospitals. Under the TDR policy, private land owners are compensated in kind if they surrender some of their land to the government for purposes such as widening a road, creating a park or slum rehabilitation. These rights can be sold to other builders or can be used for development by the builder himself in designated areas in lieu of the land that he has surrendered.
For instance, if a land parcel has been designated for roads in the plan, and the owner of that property voluntarily surrenders that land parcel to the authority, the authority will issue a TDR certificate that allows the owner to build on an equivalent area in designated areas within the plan. Typically, most TDRs have been generated through slum re-development projects and for land acquisition and for development of reservations.
TDR is a useful tool for acquiring land to implement road proposals, especially where combined land requirements are large and the authority may not always have the finances necessary for land acquisition. On the other hand this tool also benefits private land owners as only a portion of parcels has to be surrendered while the new public infrastructure investment results in improved direct accessibility inducing appreciation in property rates. It is therefore proposed that land for all road proposals should be procured through utilization of the TDR tool.
15.3.2 Accommodation Reservation
The concept of accommodation reservation facilitates development of social amenities without the planning authority having to acquire privately owned land reserved for public purposes under the development plan. Land owners are allowed to develop the required built-up area of the reservation and develop the remaining portion of the parcel as per the adjacent land use. The built-up area consumed by
15-6
the social amenity is not considered in FSI calculations thus allowing the owner to utilize the complete permissible FSI for his own use. In cases where plots are completely developed for the amenity, the TDR tool is applicable for utilizing the available FSI on another site.
Based on the nature of the reservation, the planning authority may permit the owner to operate and maintain the facility, subject to handing over the built-up area of the amenity to the authority free of all encumbrances. Thus, social amenities can be made available for public use without any financial liability on the planning authority.
Reservations such as retail markets, nursing homes and dispensaries, auditoria, public parking etc., which offer a steady revenue stream to the private land owners/facility operators are suitable for implementation using this tool.
15.3.3 Public Private Partnership
Public private partnership means an arrangement between a government/statutory entity/government owned entity on one side and a private sector entity on the other, for the provision of public assets and/or public services, through investments being made and/or management being undertaken by the private sector entity, for a specified period of time, where there is well defined allocation of risk between the private sector and the public entity and the private entity receives performance linked payments that conform (or are benchmarked) to specified and pre-determined performance standards, measurable by the public entity or its representative.
Some of the commonly adopted forms of PPPs include management contracts, build-operate-transfer (BOT) and its variants, build-lease-transfer (BLT), design-build-finance-operate-transfer (DBFOT), operatemaintain-transfer (OMT), and so on. Build-own-operate (BOO) model is normally not the supported form of Public Private Partnership in view of the finite resources of the government and complexities in imposing penalties in the event of non-performance and estimation of value of underlying assets in the event of early termination.
PPP arrangements are most suitable for projects where there is a clear revenue stream that is identifiable and linked to the asset being developed. For instance, many of the national highways have been developed under the BOT-Toll model by the National Highways Authority of India. In cases, where the asset is to be developed for public good, the annuity model is also utilized.
Facilities which offer opportunities for recovering capital and operating costs incurred for developing strategic infrastructure projects such as roads, water supply (tariff based), sewage treatment plants (for use after treatment), solid waste processing and disposal facility etc., can be developed through the PPP arrangement. However, this requires independent detailed feasibility studies to be undertaken before any project is conceptualised.