12.5.1 Comparison of Various Methods
A comparative table of the population projections for 15 years and 25 years period, by the different methodologies explained below is given in Table 12-10. The population projections for 2027 ranges from 13.20 lakhs to 15.67 lakhs while that for 2037 ranges from 14.40 lakhs to 19.69 lakhs.
| Year | Cohort Component Method | Geometric Rate Of Increase Method | Arithmetical Projections Method | Incremental Increase Method | ||
| 6 Percent Migration Rate (Business as usual scenario) | Staggered Migration Rates | 30 Percent Migration Rate (Accelerated growth scenario) | ||||
| 2012 | 1,052,223 | 1,052,223 | 1,052,223 | 1,059,568 | 1,052,592 | 1,059,090 |
| 2027 | 1,265,780 | 1,356,239 | 1,491,926 | 1,459,832 | 1,298,516 | 1,460,446 |
| 2037 | 1,376,918 | 1,592,262 | 1,876,258 | 1,938,839 | 1,463,745 | 1,807,529 |
12.5.2 Choice of Method
Each of the above-explained methodologies has its own limitations and advantages. The population projection methodologies have been summarised along with their pros and cons in Table 12-11.
| Model Examples Pros Cons TrendArithmetic Increase Minimum Data Points Its simplicity is its ExtrapolationIncremental Increase Required drawback MethodsGeometrical Method Simplistic in its application Assume a continuation of Exponential Applicable to shorter time base period trends Power Logistic period 2- 5 years Polynomial functions prone to rapid increases or rapid decreases | |||
| Cohort Component Model | Net Migration Rates | Comprehensive Model Suitable for longer projection periods | Data intensive Assumptions driven |
The appropriate model for population projection for NMA region is the Cohort Component Model for the following reasons:
The time period for population projections is 15-25 years. For such a long projection-period, the trend extrapolation methodology is not appropriate as these methods are more applicable for periods below five years.
The limitation imposed by the Cohort Component model is that it is assumptions driven. The three parameters that influence cohort component model are birth rates, mortality rates and net migration rates. Two of the three factors will vary gradually over the next two-three decades. This is because the
12-10
Replacement Rate in the region is around 2.4 and closer to the population stabilisation rate of 2.1. With literacy rates about 85 percent, the fertility rates will also tend to decline with time as there is a well-established correlation between the two. With life expectancy nearing 70 years, its increase in the forthcoming years will be very gradual thereby its contribution to the population growth will be of lesser magnitude in the past. These demographic changes also make the trend extrapolation methodologies for population projections inappropriate for the NMA region.
The Cohort Component Method is thus adopted for reasons mentioned above as the preferred population projection scenario for the NMA.
12.5.3 Growth Rate for the NMA and Conclusion on Population Projections
Given the increasing economic activities in NMA, NIT has adopted accelerated growth that is 30 percent growth rate scenario for the population projections of NMA. This means that population projections for 2032, 2027 and 2037 by Cohort Component Methodology and 30 percent growth rate is about 15 lakhs, 17 lakhs and 19 lakhs respectively.
The population projections fixed for the NMA for the Development Plan are given in Table 12-12 (all numbers are rounded).
| S No | Year | NMA population |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2011 Census | 10,33,577 |
| 2 | 2012 (Base year) | 10,60,000 |
| 2 | 2027 | 15,00,000 |
| 3 | 2032 | 17,00,000 |
| 4 | 2037 | 19,00,000 |
It is important that the economic environment is conducive for growth and can provide the necessary impetus to allow for higher population growth. The analyses for the economic environment and employment projections for the NMA is presented below in 12.6.
