The proposed reservations that are allocated on the Government lands would require no cost to acquire but only cost to develop. Acquisition of land cost is worked out by referring to the values of the land as mentioned in the Ready Reckoner 2020-21. Certain proposals are earmarked specifically for different Authorities on their demand, both, the cost of acquisition and development will be borne by the concerned Authority. Also, land required for transport networks viz., Railways, MSRDC Ring Road will be acquired by the respective agencies.
Various strategies and means of acquisition are envisaged for acquiring the above lands. Some of the tools that are adopted for land acquisition are outlined below along with their relevance to the proposed Development Plan.
Acquisition through Town Planning Schemes
The basic concept of Town Planning Scheme is pooling together all the land under different ownerships for a unified planning and thereafter subdividing and redistributing it to original landowners in a properly reconstituted form after deducting the land required for open spaces, social infrastructure, services, housing for the economically weaker section and road network. The reconstituted developed plots are allotted to the landowners in proportion to the value of their undeveloped land. Through the proposal of Development Plan, PMRDA envisages to implement 26 Town Planning Schemes which will considerably reduce the liability towards cost of acquisition of land required for the development of social infrastructure. Biggest advantage of this model is that the original landowners become partners in the subsequent developments, and this helps to increase the acceptability of this method of land consolidation.
Acquisition through Transferable Development Rights
Transferable Development Right (TDR) means a development right to transfer the potential of a plot designated for a public purpose in a Development plan. It is expressed in terms of total permissible built space and is calculated on the basis of Floor Space Index (FSI) or Floor Area Ratio (FAR) allowable for that plot which can be utilized by the owner himself or by way of transfer by him to someone else from the present location to a specified area in the plan. This can be used as additional built space over and above the permissible limit in lieu of monetary compensation for the surrender of the concerned plot to the Planning Authority.
TDR is an important instrument through which this compensation can be provided. In case of TDR the compensation is in the form of certificate which entitles the certificate owner to trade his rights in the market for cash in lieu of transferring his development rights to another individual in open market. Alternatively, he/she could utilize these rights for himself/herself.
In the transaction the acquiring party does not have to pay any monetary compensation and the private landowner gets a fair value for their under-utilized development potential. This creates a win-win situation for both the parties to the transaction.
Implementation through Accommodation Reservation
This tool enables development of amenity reservations without land acquisition. In this concept, the owner whose land is under reservation must develop certain percentage of land under reservation and surrender it to the Planning Authority. In lieu of this surrendered land, the owner shall be entitled to develop remaining land under reservation for the uses permissible in adjoining zone with full permissible FSI of the entire plot and permissible TDR potential of the entire plot.
Implementation through Reservation Credit Certificate
The reservation credit certificate is a certificate specifying the amount of compensation in lieu of handing over of reserved land to the Authority and shall be issued by the Authority. The amount mentioned in this credit certificate may be used for payment of various charges like development charges, premium charges etc. to the authority from time to time in future till exhausting the amount mentioned therein.
Implementation through Monetary Compensation
Any land required or reserved for any of the public purposes specified in the draft Development Plan may be acquired by agreement that is by paying an amount agreed to landowner (by way of private negotiations) or such land may be acquired compulsorily by the Planning Authority under the provisions of LARR Act 2013 by paying monetary compensation.
Development Plan of Pune Metropolitan Region 2021-2041
PMRDA expects that the entire land for Roads shall be consolidated through the instrument of TPS, FSI, TDR and Reservation Credit Certificate. PMRDA envisages 50% of amenity spaces to be acquired through FSI, TDR, Accommodation Reservation, Reservation Credit Certificate and the remaining 50% of amenity land to be acquired through Monetary Compensation which amounts to Rs. 1370.71 cr.
Block Cost Estimates for Construction of Roads:
The block cost estimates for the construction of all proposed roads, based on certain assumptions, are discussed in the Table above. MSRDC’s Outer Ring Road shall be developed by MSRDC. PMRDA’s Inner Ring Road shall be developed by NHAI, however, its’ cost of construction has been considered in the estimates. The block cost of road construction is about Rs. 33,991 cr.
Block Cost Estimates for Amenities:
The block cost of development of amenities is Rs. 37319.69 crores. It is proposed that amenities for education and healthcare to be developed by established Government institutions like the Zilla Parishad and the local village body (Gram Panchayat) basis the funds received through various schemes of Government of Maharashtra and Government of India. Rural healthcare infrastructure will be developed through the National Rural Health Mission or similar health sector programmes that focus upon the rural sector. Socio-Cultural and Commercial amenities like Town Halls, multipurpose market is proposed to be developed on Public Private Partnership. For Social Amenities, as far as is possible, PMRDA will encourage private sector participation and will also tap funds through Corporate Social Responsibility programmes of various entities. PMRDA shall actively engage with businesses, those in PMR, to encourage them to support and fund some of these eligible projects. At the same time, Solid Waste Management Plants, Water Treatment Plants, Sewerage Treatment Plants shall be developed by tapping into various schemes of the Government of India. PMRDA expects significant Private Sector participation as it’ll ensure effective and timebound delivery of services.
Revenue Sources:
PMRDA is established under the Maharashtra Metropolitan Region Development Authority Act which largely defines various avenues available to PMRDA for financing its activities. Various revenue streams available to PMRDA, as defined under MMRDA Act, comprise of:
• Building Permission Charges
Monetization of Land
• Share of Stamp Duty
• Return on the investments
Building Permission Charges:
Building permission department is responsible for issuance of commencement certificates and permissions for all kinds of developments – both for fresh and revised proposals – in Pune Metropolitan Region. It draws its powers to regulate and levy development and premium charges on building plans in PMR through various provisions under MRTP Act and MMRDA Act. In accordance with the sanctioned approved Development, Control & Promotion Regulations (DCPR) 2018 of PMRDA. The revenue from the Building Permission Charges has been the most dominant revenue stream. It is estimated that the revenue to PMRDA after commencement of DP shall increase exponentially because of significant increase in Developable lands.
Monetization of Land Parcels in TPS and Reserved for Authority Purpose:
Several land parcels are reserved for monetization by PMRDA in the Town Planning Schemes as well as areas outside the TPS. It should be noted that the revenue realization through these land parcels would happen in later phase of the implementation of the development plan.
PMRDA is in a process to create a systematic and structured plan to monetize its land bank. It has plans to appoint a consultant who will bring in subject matter expertise and help PMRDA achieve its goal strategically to create a stable revenue stream through monetization of various land parcels including amenity spaces.
Stamp Duty:
Current Stamp Duty structure in Pune region is 5 + 1. State legislature recently passed a law giving PMRDA claim over 25% of the 1% stamp duty collected in the Pune Metropolitan Region.
Chapter 39: Implementation Strategy and Financing Plan
Financing and Implementation Strategy:
The infrastructure development is estimated for the horizon year of 2041 to accommodate the population of 38 lacs. The infrastructure development is classified into social infrastructure development and trunk infrastructure development. Development of social infrastructure includes neighbourhood level and town level amenities. Trunk infrastructure development is applicable in equal measure to water supply, sewerage, storm water management, roads and solid waste management.
PMRDA has proposed strategic projects viz., tourism related, educational and healthcare hubs, special economic zones etc., most of these projects are amenable to PPP, which will not only reduce the initial investment of PMRDA but would also lead to revenue share to PMRDA which will be used to finance other infrastructure projects.
The Development Plan has proposed 26 TP schemes. The TP scheme mechanism allows to pool the land and replan it and redistribute it and approximately 5-10% of the area is available for monetization which recovers the cost of infrastructure and generates some additional surplus which can be used for development of other TP schemes. Thus, the proposed TP schemes will be taken up in a phased manner, which will not only lead to organized planned development, but generate revenues which will be utilized to develop the other TP schemes.
In addition, the DP has proposed 8 metro rail and is envisaged to be developed through PPP mode. PMRDA is already implementing a 23 km metro rail project on PPP route where the funds for the project are mobilized through private sector investment and viability gap funding support from Government of India & Government of Maharashtra. The development of proposed metro-corridors would be taken up in a phased manner based on comprehensive mobility plan (CMP).
The core infrastructure which is based on prior detailed studies/ master plans for water supply, sewerage, storm water drainage, solid waste management, roads etc. would need upfront investment to boost the growth. This upfront investment would be mobilized from the respective government agencies and from the government grants available through various schemes. The initial grant support will help in providing the seeding capital and would thereby promote development and generate additional funds.
Government Grants
Considering PMRDA’s limited existing revenue sources, support in terms of grants under various schemes will be required from government to meet the huge investments requirement.
External Borrowing
It is also proposed to leverage the financial resources and raise additional financing through term loans or issuance of NCDs/Bonds so long as it is able to maintain a healthy Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) and capital structure maintains an optimal opportunity cost of the capital.
It is worth noting that some of the projects in the development plan can qualify the criteria of Sustainable Development Goals, Impact Investing and Climate and Environment projects. Recent years, through efforts of government of various developed countries and multilateral agencies, have seen growth in the private and total capital available to achieve the goals of sustainable development. Also, PMRDA is actively working on developing Carbon Neutral Townships and has signed an MoU with 2000-Watt Smart City Association, Switzerland. Hence, depending upon the nature and purpose of a project, it may be able to secure funds through SDGs bonds, Green bonds, Carbon Bonds, Impact investing or grant support from various multilateral agencies.
Implementation through other allied agencies
There are few facilities and amenities which are under the domain of other government agencies e.g. power by MSEDCL & MAHATRANSCO, Police, Indian Railways, MSRDC etc. In such cases, PMRDA will request the relevant specialized agencies to take up work related to their field. At the same time, allied institutions of the Government like ZP, PMC, PCMC, MJP, PWD will provide the necessary support towards development of respective Utilities/ Amenities.