Shelter is a basic need. When the need for shelter is not satisfied, it becomes almost impossible for an individual to think of satisfying his/her family aspirations and intellectual needs. Primary responsibility of any city is to provide its residents with a decent and habitable shelter. A standard housing does not mean merely land and building, but includes basic service like water supply, sanitation and access roads.
6.02 Demand for housing is a universal phenomenon, which exists in all societies, but it varies from “no shelter” to “better shelter”; consequently it is related to economic level of households. An assessment of housing need, demand and supply becomes necessary to work out a meaningful shelter strategy.
6.03 “Housing Need” is an expression of housing requirements, and it is computed based on (i) available housing stock in the base year, (ii) no. of households at the base year, (iii) rate of demolition of dilapidated/deteriorating structures for reconstruction, and (iv) rate of clearance/conversion of ‘Katcha’/slum structures for better housing.
6.04 ‘Housing demand’ is related to market with reference to purchasing power, affordability, willingness to raise funds and it may be assessed based on the following major factors viz. (i) the economy of doing a house (temporal choices), (ii) affordability, (iii) willingness to pay (including for construction, maintenance, resource mobilization), (iv) availability and accessibility of housing finance, and (v) availability of residential plot/flats at affordable prices.
6.05 Normally, ‘housing demand’ is less than ‘housing need’ in a developing economy like ours, and these converge when society’s economic level is rich, distributed with less disparity and stable. Hence a housing policy at metropolitan level has to take into account the factors concerned with the housing needs and demand.
Housing Scenario in CMA
6.06 The decadal growth of households and housing units is given in the Table No. 6.01. (It shows that the housing requirement gap is not significant for the period 1971-91 and there is significant gap in the year 2001).
Table No. 6.01: No. of Households and Housing Units in City and CMA
Table No. 6.01: No. of Households and Housing Units in City and CMA
(in Lakhs)
Growth rate in %
1971
1981
1991
2001
1971
1981
1991
2001
Households in the City
4.44
6.29
7.96
9.62
--
41.7
26.55
20.85
Households in the CMA
6.89
9.04
11.82
16.19
31.2
30.95
36.97
Housing Units in the City
4.80
6.37
7.98
9.57
--
32.7
25.22
20.55
Housing Units in the CMA
6.63
9.15
12.34
15.83
--
38.00
34.90
29.50
Source: Census of India
6.07 The Table No.6.02 shows that the average rate of growth in housing units is declining when comparing the rate of growth of households.
Table No. 6.02: Rate of Change in Population, Households and Housing Units, 1971-2001- CMA
Annual rate of growth in population
Annual rate of growth in Households
Annual rate of growth in Housing units
1971-1981
2.76
3.12
3.27
1981-1991
2.36
3.07
3.03
1991-2001
1.93
3.69
2.63
6.08 The structural characteristics of housing stock in 2001 in Chennai City in respect of predominant materials used for wall is given in Table No.6.03 which shows that 92 percent of the houses are with ‘pucca’ walls constructed with bricks, stones, concrete and other materials.
Table No. 6.03: Chennai City Distribution of Houses by Predominant Material of Wall, 2001
Sl.No.
Type of Wall
Number of Houses
% to Total
1.
Grass, Thatch, Bamboo wood, Mud
333959
3.55
2.
Plastic, Polythene
1671
0.18
3.
Mud, Unburnt brick
29438
3.02
4.
Wood
1208
0.17
5.
GI Metal, Asbestos sheets
9061
0.95
6.
Brick
622304
65.03
7.
Stone
49363
5.16
8.
Concrete
208516
21.78
9.
Others
1556
0.16
Source: Census of India
6.09 In Chennai City 75% of the houses are with roof made up of brick, stone, concrete and other materials of pucca nature, about 15% are with semi-pucca roofing materials such as tiles, slate, G.I. metal sheets and asbestos cement sheets, and about 10% are with ‘Katcha’ materials such as thatched, bamboo etc.
Table No. 6.04: Distribution of Houses by Predominant Nature of Roof – Chennai City
Sl.No.
Type
Number of Houses
% total
1.
Grass Thatch, Bamboo, Wood, Mud, etc.
90,735
9.48
2.
Plastic and Polythene
2,966
0.31
3.
Tiles
71,403
7.46
4.
Slate
1,662
0.17
5
GI metal, Asbestos sheets
65392
6.83
6
Brick
18908
1.98
7
Stone
5246
0.55
8
Concrete
696997
72.83
9
Any Other Material
3767
0.39
Source: Census of India
6.10 Even though the proportion of the housing units with ‘Katcha’ roofing materials accounts for only about 10%, in absolute numbers it is large i.e., 93,701 and these are vulnerable to fire accidents, particularly in summer months and every such occurrences of fire accidents burn down the whole area of such thatched roofed slums which is common in Chennai city, some times resulting in casualties. The proportion of dilapidated / deteriorating housing units accounts for only about 0.5% of the total households.
Table No. 6.05: Distribution of Houses by Predominant Nature of Floor – Chennai City
Sl.No.
Type
Number of Houses
% total
1.
Mud
32729
3.42
2.
Wood Bamboo
1003
0.10
3.
Brick
4782
0.50
4.
Stone
5712
0.60
5.
Cement
611892
63.93
6.
Mosaic & Floor tiles
296953
31.03
7.
Any other material
4005
0.42
Souce: Census of India
6.11 According to Census, 2001, about 71% of households live in less than three roomed housing units; proportion of households which live in one roomed, two roomed, three roomed houses etc. is given in the Table No.6.06
Table No.6.06: Distribution of Households by Number of Dwelling Rooms – Chennai City, 2001
Number of Rooms
Households
% Total
No. of Exclusive Rooms
205020
02.47
One Room
318325
38.45
Two Rooms
251659
30.40
Three Rooms
144149
17.41
Four Rooms
57555
06.95
Five Rooms
17938
02.16
Six Rooms and above
17665
02.13
Source: Census of India
6.12 The study on “Shelter Strategy” conducted by the School of Architecture and Planning (Anna University) for PMG, Govt. of Tamil nadu (1995) revealed the following:
(i) The total households in CMA during 1991 were 12.17 lakh consisting of 9 lakh in the non-slum category and 3.17 in the slum category.
(ii) The total number of houses in CMA during 1991 was 12.72 lakh consisting of 9 lakh units in the non-slum and 2.72 lakh units in the slum categories respectively.
(iii) Among the non-slum households 18% belong to EWS, 30% belong to LIG, 22% belong to MIG and 30% belong to HIG.
(iv) Among the slum households 86% belong to EWS, 13% belong to LIG and 1% belongs to MIG and HIG.
(v) 44% of the houses are with one bedroom, 35% with multipurpose room, 17% with two-bed room, and 4% with 3 and more bedrooms.
(vi) 3.47 lakh housing units were delivered in CMA during the decade 1981-91, out of which a little more than half i.e. 1.81 lakh units (52%) were plots, 1.07 lakh units (31%) were houses and only 0.59 lakh units (17%) were flats.
(vii) Out of the total housing units delivered by TNHB, 51% are meant for EWS, 24% are for LIG, 12% are for MIG and 13% are for HIG.
(viii) TNSCB has taken up more than fourteen different schemes out of which ten schemes are meant for physical improvement of slums and four schemes are meant for financial assistance to the slum households for improving their shelter units.
(ix) TNSCB has delivered as much as about 12,000 tenements, about 700 houses and about 5000 serviced plots. Nearly 1.88 lakh households were benefited under different environmental improvement schemes.
(x) The annual delivery rate of all the housing units put together was 16,000 during 1981 which increased to 41000 units during 1991, an increase 1.5 times. The annual delivery rate of plots alone was 10,000 units during 1981, which increased to 18,000 units during 1991, an increase of 80%. The annual delivery of houses has registered a 150% increase from about 7000 units during 1981 to about 18,000 units during 1991. The annual delivery rate of flats increased from 1,000 units during 1983 to about 6,000 units during 1991, a fivefold increase.
(xi) Most of the plots delivered under MUDP I, II and TNUDP were meant for EWS and LIG.
(xii) In the case of MUDP I, II & TNUDP, the above facilities were provided with better quality as the cost per family sanctioned was more. Further under these World Bank aided schemes, patta for the site under enjoyment was also issued to the beneficiary in addition to making available the loan for improvement/construction house.
6.13 Study on “Effective Demand for Housing in Tamil Nadu” was conducted in 1995 by the Consultants M/s. STEM for PMG, Govt. of Tamil Nadu. Covering a sample size of 2,255 households in respect of Chennai Urban Agglomeration. The following were the outcome of the study.
(i) Social Profile of Households
Madras Urban Agglomeration is spread over Madras and part of the Chengalpattu-MGR District. Total estimated households are 1.14 million covering 5.4 million population. Nearly 92 % of SC & ST households are from lower income groups i.e., EWS and LIG. The percentage of male population is more than (52 %) female population (48% per cent) in MUA. More than 8% are above 59 years of age group. Two out of every three households have been staying at the same place for more than 20 years. Nearly 45% of the households have migrated to MUA. While more than 75% of migrant households moved in from other towns, thus urban-urban migration is a major flow. About 10% of migrant households are from other states and 51% from the same district. Majority of migrants from other states fall in the higher income groups. About 30% of households migrated only for employment purpose, followed by movement of household or spouse.
(ii) Economic Profile of Households
About 38% of the households have an income less than Rs.1101 per month, while 9% draw less than Rs.501 per month. 3% of the households have an income of less than Rs.250 per month. EWS and LIG groups account for 72% of the households. The city, thus, has more of poor people houses, on the ground than of rich people
houses, as a skyline. In the case of EWS, the expenditure is more than their monthly income. Major source of income is wages, salary and pension for 90% of households, other investments account only 7%. Of the earning head of households 14% are above 59 years of age and 6% are females as head of households. Only 29% of the members are earners. And only 28% of the households have assets. About 76% of a household's expenditure go for the major and main item of food and essential.
(iii) Physical Profile of Buildings
Nearly 77% of the buildings are accessible through tar roads, and only 14% are approachable through mud roads. 36% of EWS buildings and 31% of LIG buildings roofs and walls are of temporary materials namely thatch/grass. 35% of EWS buildings are dilapidated. 18% of the buildings comprise flats and 41% are independent buildings. 8% of the buildings are put to residential and commercial uses. 53% of the buildings are within 20 years of age. 14% are between 20 to 40 years of age. Nearly 7% of buildings are of more than 3 floors. On an average 2.81 households occupy each building. Average house cost is thrice the annual income of a household.
(iv) Amenities
On an average only 12% of the households have no power supply, however in the case of EWS category nearly one in four households have no electric connection. Municipal water supply, own well or bore well, public tap or hand pump together cover around 89% of the households. 71% of the households have private bathing facilities. 70% of the households have private toilet facility. 65% of households have facilities to dispose sewage into municipal connections and 33% have septic tank or soak pit and remaining percent have open drain and dry latrines. Availability of amenities increases with the rise in income and EWS has far less amenities than others.
(v) Tenure Status and Mode of Property Acquisition
About 46% of the buildings are rented houses and 54% are own houses. Nearly 95% of tenant households do not have any property. Of the owned households, 23% are ancestral property and 22% are purchased from private party. 32% of the households have made full payment for purchased property and only 7% have paid partial payment. Percentage of houses owned increases with rise in income.
(vi) Perceptions on Major Problems in Housing
Arranging own funds and obtaining a loan were found to be time consuming and difficult, more than 25% of households found it very difficult. Preparation of plans and getting them approved were difficult for more than 30% and very difficult for 18% of the
households. Getting water, sewerage and electricity connections were not a problem for nearly 40% of the households. Getting skilled workmen was not a problem in urban areas like Madras.
(vii) Housing Needs and Demand
Housing needs were computed for 3 scenarios. Housing needs vary from 10% to 23% of total housing stock. In the EWS category, it varies from 19% to 40% units. The housing demand is computed for 5 scenarios. It varies from 1.61% to 22%. The effective housing demand should be based on mixed socio-economic variables. EWS households who desire a house, but cannot afford it, do not come under housing demand and need to be addressed separately.
Slums
6.14 The Government of India Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act of 1954 defines a slum as "any predominantly residential area where the dwellings by reason of dilapidation, overcrowding, faulty arrangement, lack of ventilation, light or sanitary facilities or any combination of these factors are detrimental to safety, health or morals. In 1971, the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board, drafting officials from Survey, Statistical, Revenue and Town Planning Departments then, conducted Socio-Economic survey of Madras Slums. For the purpose of the survey, a slum was taken to mean “hutting areas with huts erected in a haphazard manner without proper access, without protected water supply and drainage arrangements and so congested as to allow a little free flow of air to get in”. Some of the observations found made in the report are extracted below:
“Slums generally present the most unhygienic, ugliest, nauseating scene. During rainy season, the whole area gets flooded, the pathways become swampy and the entire colony become as fertile breeding place for mosquitoes, exposing the slum dwellers living in the area to all sorts of diseases. During summer, the thatched huts are prone to fire accidents. Thus, the slum dwellers’ life is the most miserable one, devoid of all basic amenities.
6.15 To ease the difficulties of the slum dwellers, attempts were made earlier to clear the slums in Madras City. In North Madras, the Corporation of Madras and in South Madras the City Improvement Trust and subsequently, the Tamil Nadu Housing Board were looking after the slum clearance work. They, apart from constructing flats for the low and middle income groups, allotted open developed plots, measuring 20’ x 40’ in certain areas to slum families. However, further allotments required vast areas of land, and the scheme was given up owing to scarcity of land within the City.
6.16 The Government of Tamil Nadu hold the view that slums are not acts of God, but of human folly and that they can be banished by wise planning and resolute action.
6.17 The Tamil Nadu Government realized that the feeble, halting, incomplete and disconcerted measures of the past have to give place to a comprehensive, integrated and concerted policy to be put through on an emergency footing. It also realized that unless programmes of slum clearance and settlements of slum dwellers are drawn on a more realistic basis, relating them to economic opportunities and provision of social services and social welfare services, the results may well turn out to be frustrating. It also recognized the fact that the slum dwellers are an essential element in city life, and that they are as necessary as any other section of the population for the life of the city.”
6.18 The TNSCB was formed in 1970 and the Tamil Nadu Slum (Improvement and Clearance) Act, was enacted in 1971. The following are the objectives of the Board:
(1) To clear all the slums in Madras city within a targeted period,
(2) To prevent further growth of slums in Madras city,
(3) To give protection to the slum dwellers from eviction and to re-house them in modern tenements and
(4) To provide basic amenities such as drinking water supply, electricity, storm water drainage etc. to certain slum areas until they are finally cleared.
6.19 The Socio-economic Survey 1971 has brought out the characteristics of slums. Main findings are
(1) Causes of slums in Chennai:
(i) Poverty - Frequent failure of monsoons led to mass influx of agricultural labourers from the adjoining districts to the City. After coming to the City they pick up any manual job (unmindful of the hardships) such as head load carriers, rickshaw-pullers, cart-pullers, domestic servants, petty vendors, carpenters, masons and other manual works. The income they derive from their jobs was very low which was hardly sufficient for a balanced diet, so they were unable to pay for rents for securing decent dwellings and hence squatted on open spaces available near their work spots.
(ii) Physical conditions - The low-lying areas and waterfronts served as fertile grounds for the growth of slums.
(2) Out of the City extent (then) of 128.83 sq.km. slums covered about 6 percent of the total area. They were situated in government lands, City Corporation lands, and Housing Board lands, lands of religious institutions and private land as detailed in Table No.6.07.
Table No.6.07: Ownership of Lands Occupied by Slums, 1971
Sl.No.
Ownership of land
Percentage of slum families to the total slum families
1.
Private
31.96
2.
Corporation
08.11
3.
Government (State)
35.69
4.
Housing Board / Slum Clearance Board
13.09
5.
Port Trust
0.03
6.
Hindu Religious Endowment / Wakf Board / other missions
09.01
7.
Others
02.12
6.20 In order to provide a comprehensive data base on the number, location and type of slums and their population for overall planning and implementation of specific programmes, CMDA had drawn the services of the consultants M/s. Economist Group, Chennai to conduct the survey of slums in the CMA; it was conducted between April and December, 1986. In this survey, the number of shelter within slums were collected in respect of the slums which were not covered (then) under MUDP I & MUDP II and slum clearance schemes of TNSCB.
Table No.6.08: Survey of Slums in MMA - Slum Population in the Study Region – Covered under MUDP/Clearance, 1986
Zone
Corporation Divisions
MUDP I S F
MUDP II S F
Clearance S F
S
All F
I Extended Areas
8
3
5276
39
7319
6
2925
48
15520
III South Madras
69
19
3192
70
14060
72
24169
161
41421
IV North Madras
73
51
14102
121
25978
40
17576
212
57656
Madras City
150
73
22570
230
47357
118
44670
421
114597
II Towns in MUA
10 Towns
3
1709
10
3408
-
-
13
5117
MUA
-
76
24279*
240
50765
118
44670
434
119714
Source: Survey of slums in MMA, 1986
S – Slums F – Families Socio-economic part of it was concerned estimation were made based on sample survey.
For the purpose of that study, CMA had been divided into four as follows:
Zone-I - Extended areas of the City covering 10 towns in 8 Corporation Divisions
Zone-II - Peripheral areas comprising 10 towns in the MUA
Zone-III - Madras City : South having 69 Corporation Divisions
Zone-IV - Madras City : North with 73 Corporation Divisions
6.21 Statistics on the growth of slum households and slum population is given in Table below.
Table No.6.09: Growth of Slums in Chennai City
Sl.No.
Year
No. of slums
No. of the households
Slum Population
1.
1956
306
57,436
2,87,180
2.
1961
548
97,851
4,12,168
3.
1971
1202
1,63,802
7,37,531
4.
1986
996*
1,27,181
6,50,859
5.
2001
1431(CMA)
1,78,000
8,20,000
Pavement Dwellers:
6.22 According to Survey of Pavement-dweller in Chennai City conducted by the consultant SPARC for CMDA in 1989-90, the number of households who were living on pavements was 9491 at 405 clusters at an average of about 23 households at a place; their population was 40,763 (20,811 Male and 19,950 Female) with 40.2% children population. Unlike other old cities in India namely Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkotta the number of pavement dwellers in Chennai is relatively few.
Delivery of Housing
6.23 The delivery agencies in CMA can be broadly classified as public, co-operative and private sector. Under the public sector, the agencies operating mainly are TNHB and TNSCB; the agencies which provided housing to its employees are TNPHC, Railways, P&T and CPWD, Port Trust, etc.
Tnphc
6.26 Tamil Nadu Police Housing Corporation was established in 1981 to effectively implement schemes for providing adequate housing facilities for the police personnel. It has delivered 4,702 housing units from 1992 to 2002; there are 1,509 housing units under construction by it at various parts of CMA and their proposals in the anvil include construction of 1,378 housing units.
6.27 The Shelter Strategy Study conducted by School of Planning and Architecture, in 1991 revealed that the public agencies had delivered total housing units of 10,555 Nos. from 1981 to 1991 [CPWD (1,854 Nos.), P&T (1,572 Nos.), Railways (2,400 Nos.) Port Trust (500 Nos.), TNPHC (104 Nos.), THADCO (1,125 Nos., and others (3,000 Nos.)].
Tamil Nadu Housing Board
6.24 Tamil Nadu Housing Board was established as a statutory body in 1961 under the Tamil Nadu State Housing Board Act, 1961.
6.25 TNHB has been delivering the housing under their different programmes viz. regular programme, MUDP & TNUDP. TNHB was delivering serviced plots and constructed houses and flats under these programmes. TNHB had developed large neighbourhoods with all amenities and facilities within CMA at Arignar Anna Nagar, K.K. Nagar, Ashok Nagar, Bharathi Nagar, South Madras Neighbourhood Scheme (comprising Indira Nagar, Besant Nagar and Sashtri Nagar), Thiruvanmiyur, Tambaram etc. TNHB has also developed Sites and Services Schemes under MUDP-I, MUDP-II and TNUDP at Arumbakkam, Villivakkam, Kodungaiyur, Mogappair (East), Mogappair (West), Maduravoyal, Manali, Madhavaram, Ambattur, Avadi and Velachery. The details of the housing delivered under MUDP & TNUDP is given in the Table No.6.10.
Table No. 6.10: Details of Sites and Services Projects under MUDP & TNUDP