A comprehensive evaluation system should be developed in consultation with CMDA, taking into account all relevant factors such as capital and operational costs and environmental, social and political factors, services to the poor and vulnerable. The evaluation should be comprehensive, on the basis of four major criteria: (i) economically viable; (ii) socially acceptable; (iii) environmentally sustainable; and (iv) financially feasible. At the strategic planning level, a preliminary assessment of economic and financial feasibility and social and environmental impacts should be made for each proposed alternative strategy. In defining the alternative strategies, the consultant should pay special attention to the services to poor and the vulnerable.
The comprehensive evaluation should result in the recommendation of a preferred long term transport strategy. The consultant in collaboration with CMDA and other transport agencies should explain the basis for its recommendations.
Task 3.7 Prepare a Draft Transport Strategy Document
The outline strategy should amount to a directional plan indicating the main imperatives of transport policy during the foreseeable future, having regard to need, desirability (with regard to factors such as land use development and environmental and social impacts), affordability and uncertainty. This strategy should take account of economic growth, current initiatives of CMDA, the need to conserve and enhance the urban environment, land use plans and likely land use development patterns.
The strategy document should cover the following patterns:
i) Current Situation. Clarification in broad but objective terms of the current situation and trends: the quantity of personal movement by commuter rail, bus, car, autorickshaws, NMT, two-wheelers, taxis, water transport and on foot; the amount of goods vehicle movement; Intercity traffic, long distance Bus / Railway passenger movement; origin-destination patterns; current problems.
ii) Traffic Growth. Clarification of current growth rates, potential growth rates (with reference to experience elsewhere), potential problems.
iii) Current Constraints. Clarification of current constraints with regard to government policies on vehicle licensing, vehicle and fuel prices and trends, land use policies and the resources available for transport investment and the scope of cost recovery through direct user charges such as tolls
iv) Long Term Trends and Prospects. Review of implications for transport (supply and demand) of economic growth and land use developments; and of the implications for transport planning of uncertainty.
v) Transport Investment Options. Review of the main means of providing additional transport capacity with regard to their effectiveness, magnitude of orders of cost (including both capital and recurrent costs), economic and financial viability, etc. including;
vi) Demand Management. The need for and means of achieving the management of the potentially high growth in the use of motor vehicles (including motorcycles).
vii) Environmental Measures. Review the need for measures to ameliorate adverse environmental impacts, either existing or resulting from proposed projects or increased development.
viii) Land Use Strategy. Review of the scope and limitations of reducing / controlling traffic demands through land use policy and of the scope for using transport policy to influence land use development.
ix) Institutional Arrangement. A diagnostic assessment of the current institutional arrangements for administering and planning transport activities in CMA, including policy formulation, regulation of transport operations, financing, and investments, and recommendations for improving the arrangement.
x) Conclusions and Recommendations on Transport Strategy.
Broad conclusions and priorities for development of commuter rail, bus transit, highway construction, goods transport and interregional bus / rail transport, water transport, ferry services, traffic management and demand management in short, medium, and long terms; observations on land use strategy.