The simulation software shall be a computer-based program for the analysis of energy consumption in buildings and be approved by the authority having jurisdiction. The simulation program shall, at a minimum, have the ability to model the following:
a) Energy flows on an hourly basis for all 8,760 hours of the year,
b) Hourly variations in occupancy, lighting power, miscellaneous equipment power, thermostat set points, and HVAC system operation, defined separately for each day of the week and holidays,
c) Thermal mass effects,
d) Ten or more thermal zones,
e) Part-load and temperature dependent performance of heating and cooling equipment,
f) Air-side and water-side economizers with integrated control.
In addition to the above, the simulation tool shall be able to produce hourly reports of energy use by energy source and shall have the capability to performing design load calculations to determine required HVAC equipment capacities, air, and water flow rates in accordance with §5 for both the proposed and Standard building designs.
The simulation program shall be tested according to ASHRAE Standard 140 Method of Test for the Evaluation of Building Energy Analysis Computer Programs (ANSI approved) and the results shall be furnished by the software provider.
9.3.2 Climate Data
The simulation program shall use hourly values of climatic data, such as temperature and humidity, from representative climatic data for the city in which the Proposed Design is to be located. For cities or urban regions with several climate data entries, and for locations where weather data are not available, the designer shall select available weather data that best represent the climate at the construction site.
9.3.3 Compliance Calculations
The Proposed Design and Standard Design shall be calculated using the following:
a) Same simulation program,
b) Same weather data, and
c) Identical building operation assumptions (thermostat set points, schedules, equipment and occupant loads, etc.) unless an exception is allowed by this Code or the authority having jurisdiction for a given category.
9.4Calculating Energy Consumption of Proposed Design and Standard Design
9.4.1 Energy Simulation Model
The simulation model for calculating the Proposed Design and the Standard Design shall be developed in accordance with the requirements in Table 9-1. The Standard Design is based on the mandatory and prescriptive requirements of the ECBC compliant building. The Standard Design will be the same for all compliance levels (ECBC, ECBC+, Super ECBC).
Chapter 9Whole Building Performance Method
9.1 General
9.1.1 Scope
The Whole Building Performance Method is an alternative to the Prescriptive Method compliance path contained in §4 through §7 of this Code. It applies to all building types covered by the Code as mentioned in §2.5.
9.1.2 Compliance
A building complies with the Code using the Whole Building Performance (WBP) Method, when the estimated EPI Ratio is equal to or less than 1, even though it may not comply with the specific provisions of the prescriptive requirements in §4 trough §7. The mandatory requirements of §4 through §7 (§4.2, §5.2, §6.2, and §7.2) shall be met when using the WBP Method.
9.1.3 Annual Energy Use
Annual energy use for the purposes of the WBP Method shall be calculated in kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity use per year per unit area. Energy sources other than electricity that are used in the building shall be converted to kWh of electric energy at the rate of 0.75 kWh per megajoule.
Note: The annual energy use calculation as per the Whole Building Performance Method is not a prediction of the actual energy use of the building once it gets operational. Actual energy performance of a building depends on a number of factors like weather, occupant behaviour, equipment performance and maintenance, among others, which are not covered by this Code.
9.1.4 Trade-offs Limited to Building Permit
The WBP Method may be used for building permit applications that include less than the whole building; however, any design parameters that are not part of the building permit application shall be identical for both the Proposed Design and the Standard Design. Future improvements to the building shall comply with both the mandatory and prescriptive requirements of concurrent code.
9.1.5 Documentation Requirements
Compliance shall be documented and compliance forms shall be submitted to the authority having jurisdiction. The information submitted shall include, at a minimum, the following:
a) Summary describing the results of the analysis, including the annual energy use for the Proposed Design and the Standard Design, and software used.
b) Brief description of the project with location, number of stories, space types, conditioned and unconditioned areas, hours of operation.
c) List of the energy-related building features of the Proposed Design. This list shall also document features different from the Standard Design.
d) List showing compliance with the mandatory requirements of this code.
e) The input and output report(s) from the simulation program including a breakdown of energy usage by at least the following components: lights, internal equipment loads, service water heating equipment, space heating equipment, space cooling and heat rejection equipment, fans, and other HVAC equipment (such as pumps). The output reports shall also show the number of hours any loads are not met by the HVAC system for both the Proposed Design and Standard Design.
f) Explanation of any significant modelling assumptions made.
g) Explanation of any error messages noted in the simulation program output.
h) Building floor plans, building elevations, and site plan.
9.2 Mandatory Requirements
All requirements of §4.2, §5.2, §6.2, and §7.2 shall be met. These sections contain the mandatory provisions of the Code and are prerequisites for demonstrating compliance using the WBP Method.
9.4.2HVAC Systems
The HVAC system type and related performance parameters for the Standard Design shall be determined from Table 9-2 and the following rules:
a) Other components: Components and parameters not listed in Table 9-2 or otherwise specifically addressed in this subsection shall be identical to those in the Proposed Design. Exception to § 9.4.2(a): Where there are specific requirements in §5.2.2, the component efficiency in the Standard Design shall be adjusted to the lowest efficiency level allowed by the requirement for that component type.
b) All HVAC and service water heating equipment in the Standard Design shall be modeled at the minimum efficiency levels, both part load and full load, in accordance with §5.2.2.
c) Where efficiency ratings, such as EER and COP, include fan energy, the descriptor shall be broken down into its components so that supply fan energy can be modeled separately.
d) Minimum outdoor air ventilation rates shall be the same for both the Standard Design and the Proposed Design except for conditions specified in §9.4.2.1.
e) The equipment capacities for the Standard Design shall be sized proportionally to the capacities in the Proposed Design based on sizing runs; i.e., the ratio between the capacities used in the annual simulations and the capacities determined by the sizing runs shall be the same for both the Proposed Design and Standard Design.
f) Unmet load hours for the Proposed Design shall not differ from unmet load hours for the Standard Design by more than 50 hours. Maximum number of unmet hours shall not exceed 300 for either case.
Table 9-1Modelling Requirements for Calculating Proposed and Standard Design
Case
Proposed Design
Standard Design
1. Design Model
a) The simulation model of the Proposed Design shall be consistent with the design documents, including proper accounting of fenestration and opaque envelope types and area; interior lighting power and controls; HVAC system types, sizes, and controls; and service water heating systems and controls.b) When the whole building performance method is applied to buildings in which energy-related features have not been designed yet (e.g., a lighting system), those yet-to-be-designed features shall be described in the Proposed Design so that they minimally comply with applicable mandatory and prescriptive requirements of §4.2, §5.2, §6.2, and §7.2 and §4.3, §5.3, and §6.3 respectively.
The Standard Design shall be developed by modifying the Proposed Design as described in this table.Unless specified in this table, all building systems and equipment shall be modeled identically in the Standard Design and Proposed Design.
2. Space Use Classification
The building type or space type classifications shall be chosen in accordance with §2.5. More than one building type category may be used in a building if it is a mixed-use facility.
Same as Proposed Design.
3. Schedules
Operational schedules (hourly variations in occupancy, lighting power, equipment
Same as Proposed Design.
power, HVAC equipment operation, etc.) suitable for the building and/or space type shall be modeled for showing compliance. Schedules must be modeled as per §9.6. In case a schedule for an occupancy type is missing in §9.6, appropriate schedule may be used. Temperature and humidity schedules and set points shall be identical in the Standard and Proposed Designs. Temperature control/ thermostat throttling ranges shall also be modeled identically in both the Designs
Exception: Schedules may be allowed to differ between the Standard and Proposed models wherever it is necessary to model nonstandard efficiency measures and/ or measures which can be best approximated by a change in schedule. Measures that may warrant a change in operating schedules include but are not limited to automatic controls for lighting, natural ventilation, demand controlled ventilation systems, controls for service water heating load reduction. Schedule change is not allowed for manual controls under any category. This is subject to approval by the authority having jurisdiction.
4.Building Envelope
All components of the building envelope in the Proposed Design shall be modeled as shown on architectural drawings or as installed for existing building envelopes. Exceptions: The following building elements are permitted to differ from architectural drawings. a)Any envelope assembly that covers less than 5% of the total area of that assembly type (e.g., exterior walls) need not be separately described. If not separately described, the area of an envelope assembly must be added to the area of the adjacent assembly of that same type. b)Exterior surfaces whose azimuth orientation and tilt differ by no more than 45 degrees and are otherwise the same may be described as either a single surface or by using multipliers.
The Standard Design shall have identical conditioned floor area and identical exterior dimensions and orientations as the Proposed Design, except as noted in (a), (b), (c), and (d) below. a)Orientation. The Standard Design performance shall be generated by simulating the building with its actual orientation and again after rotating the entire building 90, 180, 270 degrees, then averaging the results. The building shall be modeled so that it does not shade itself. b)Opaque assemblies such as roof, floors, doors, and walls shall be modeled as
c) For exterior roofs, other than roofs with ventilated attics, the reflectance and emittance of the roof surface shall be modeled in accordance with§4.3.1.1.d)Manually operated fenestration shading devices such as blinds or shades shall not be modeled. Permanent shading devices such as fins, overhangs, and light shelves shall be modeled. e)The exterior roof surface shall be modeled using the solar reflectance in accordance with ASTM E903-96 and thermal emittance determined in accordance with ASTM E408-71. Where cool roof is proposed, emittance and reflectance shall be modeled as per ASTM E408-71 and ASTM E903-96 respectively. Where cool roof is not proposed, the exterior roof surface shall be modeled with a reflectance of 0.3 and a thermal emittance of 0.9.
having the same heat capacity as the Proposed Design but with the maximum U-factor allowed in §4.3.1 and §4.3.1.1. c) Fenestration. Fenestration areas shall equal that in the Proposed Design or 40% of gross above grade wall area, whichever is smaller, and shall be distributed on each face in the same proportions as in the Proposed Design No shading projections are to be modeled; fenestration shall be assumed to be flush with the exterior wall or roof. Manually operated fenestration shading devices such as blinds or shades shall not be modeled. Fenestration U-factor shall be the maximum allowed for the climate, and the solar heat gain coefficient shall be the maximum allowed for the climate and orientation. d)Roof Solar Reflectance and Thermal Emittance: The exterior roof surfaces shall be modeled using a solar reflectance of 0.6 and a thermal emittance of 0.9.
5.Lighting
Lighting power in the Proposed Design shall be determined as follows: Where a complete lighting system exists, the actual lighting power shall be used in the model. Where a lighting system has been designed, lighting power shall be determined in accordance with either§6.3.4.
Lighting power in the Standard Design shall be determined using the same categorization procedure (building area or space function) and categories as the Proposed Design with lighting power set equal to the maximum allowed for the
Where no lighting exists, or is specified, lighting power shall be determined in accordance with the §6.3.2 or §6.3.3 for the appropriate building type. Lighting system power shall include all lighting system components shown or provided for on plans (including lamps, ballasts, task fixtures, and furniture-mounted fixtures). Lighting power for parking garages and building facades shall be modeled. Minimum Lighting controls, as per the ECBC requirements of §6.2.1, shall be modeled in the Proposed case. Automatic daylighting controls shall be modeled directly in the software or through schedule adjustments determined by a separate daylight analysis approved by the authority having jurisdiction. Other automatic lighting controls shall be modeled directly in the software by adjusting the lighting power as per Table9-4.
corresponding method and category in either §6.3.2 or §6.3.3. Power for fixtures not included in the lighting power density calculation shall be modeled identically in the Proposed Design and Standard Design. Lighting controls shall be as per the ECBC requirements of §6.2.1.
6.HVAC Thermal Zones
HVAC Zones Designed: Where HVAC zones are defined on design drawings, each HVAC zone shall be modeled as a separate thermal block. Exception: Identical zones (similar occupancy and usage, similar internal loads, similar set points and type of HVAC system, glazed exterior walls face the same orientation or vary by less than 45°) may be combined for simplicity. HVAC Zones Not Designed: Where HVAC zones are not defined on design drawings, HVAC zones shall be defined based on similar occupancy and usage, similar internal loads, similar set points and type of HVAC system, glazed exterior walls that face the same orientation or vary by less than 45° in combination with the following rules:
Same as Proposed Design
Perimeter Core Zoning: Separate thermal block shall be modeled for perimeter and core spaces. Perimeter spaces are defined as spaces located within 5 meters of an exterior or semi exterior wall. Core spaces are defined as spaces located greater than 5 meters of an exterior or semi exterior wall. Separate thermal blocks shall be modeled for floors in contact with ground and for floors which have a ceiling/roof exposure to the ambient.
7.
The HVAC system type and all related The HVAC system type shall
HVAC Systems
performance parameters, such as be as per Table 9-2 and equipment capacities and efficiencies, in related performance the Proposed Design shall be determined parameters for the Standard as follows: Design shall be determined a)Where a complete HVAC system exists, from requirements of §9.4.2. the model shall reflect the actual Equipment performance shall system type using actual component meet the requirements of §5 capacities and efficiencies. for code compliant building. b)Where an HVAC system has been designed, the HVAC model shall be consistent with design documents. Mechanical equipment efficiencies shall be adjusted from actual design conditions to the rating conditions specified in §5, if required by the simulation model. c) Where no heating system has been specified, the heating system shall be assumed to be electric. The system characteristics shall be identical to the system modeled in the Standard Design. d)Where no cooling system has been specified, the cooling system and its characteristics shall be identical to the system modeled in the Standard Design.
8.
The service hot water system type and all The service water heating
Service Hot
related performance parameters, such as system shall be of the same
Water
equipment capacities and efficiencies, in type as the Proposed Design.
the Proposed Design shall be determined as follows: a)Where a complete service hot water system exists, the model shall reflect the actual system type using actual component capacities and efficiencies. b)Where a service hot water system has been designed, the service hot water model shall be consistent with design documents. c) Where no service hot water system exists, or is specified, no service hot water heating shall be modeled.
For residential facilities, hotels and hospitals the Standard Design shall have a solar hot water system capable of meeting 20% of the hot water demand. Systems shall meet the efficiency requirements of §5.2.9.2, the pipe insulation requirements of §5.2.9.4 and incorporate heat traps in accordance with §5.2.9.5.
9.Miscellaneous Loads
Receptacle, motor, and process loads shall be modeled and estimated based on the building type or space type category. These loads shall be included in simulations of the building and shall be included when calculating the Standard Design and Proposed Design. All end-use load components within and associated with the building shall be modeled, unless specifically excluded by this Table, but not limited to, exhaust fans, parking garage ventilation fans, exterior building lighting, swimming pool heaters and pumps, elevators and escalators, refrigeration equipment, and cooking equipment.
Receptacle, motor and process loads shall be modeled the same as the Proposed Design.
10.Modelling Limitations to the Simulation Program
If the simulation program cannot model a component or system included in the Proposed Design, one of the following methods shall be used with the approval of the authority having jurisdiction: a)Ignore the component if the energy impact on the trade-offs being considered is not significant. b)Model the component substituting a thermodynamically similar component model. c) Model the HVAC system components or systems using the HVAC system of the Standard Design in accordance with Section 6 of this table. d) Whichever method is selected, the component shall be modeled identically for both the Proposed Design and Standard Design models.
Same as Proposed Design.
Table 9-2HVAC Systems Map for Standard Design
Hotel/Motel, Hospital Patient Rooms, Hotel Guest Rooms, Resorts, Villas, Sleeping Quarters in Mixed-use Buildings, Schools, Classrooms/LectureRooms1
Buildings with Less than or Equal to 12,500 m² of Conditioned Area
Buildings with More than 12,500 m² of Conditioned Area
Data Centre/ Server/ComputerRooms
Name
System A
System B
System C
System D
System Type2
Split AC
VRF : Variable Refrigerant Flow
VAV: Central cooling plant with variable volume AHU for each zone
Computer Room air conditioners
Fan Control
Constant Volume
Constant volume
Variable volume
Constant volume
Cooling Type
Direct expansion with air cooled condenser
Direct expansion with air cooled condenser
Chilled Water with water cooled condenser
Direct expansion with air cooled condenser
Heating Type
1. Heat Pump: Where no heating system has been specified or where an electric heating system has been
1. Heat Pump: Where no heating system has been specified or where an electric heating system has
1. Electric resistance: Where no heating system has been specified or where an electric heating
NA
specified in the Proposed Design 2. Fossil Fuel Boiler: Where a heating system exists and a fossil fuel hot water boiler has been specified in the Proposed Design
been specified in the Proposed Design 2. Fossil Fuel Boiler: Where a heating system exists and a fossil fuel hot water boiler has been specified in the Proposed Design
system has been specified in the Proposed Design 2. Fossil Fuel Boiler: Where a heating system exists and a fossil fuel hot water boiler has been specified in the Proposed Design
Notes: 1. Buildings of the listed occupancy types or spaces in Mixed-use Buildings with the listed occupancy types. 2. Where attributes make a building eligible for more than one system type; use the predominant condition to determine the Standard Design system type provided the non-predominant conditions apply to less than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for non-predominant conditions if those conditions apply to more than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for any space which has a substantial difference in peak loads and/ or operational hours compared to the predominant space type. Such spaces may include but are not limited to computer/ server rooms, retail areas in residential, or office buildings.
9.4.2.1 Minimum Outdoor air rates:
Minimum outdoor air rates shall be identical for both the Standard Design and Proposed Design, except
a) when modeling demand controlled ventilation (DCV) in the Proposed Design (DCV is not required in the Standard Design as per §5.2.1.4)
b) when the Proposed Design has a minimum ventilation flow higher than the minimum required by the applicable code, the Standard Design shall be modeled as per the
minimum ventilation rate required by the applicable code and the Proposed Design shall be modeled as per actual design (higher than Standard Design)
9.4.2.2 Fan Schedules
Supply and return fans shall operate continuously whenever the spaces are occupied and shall be cycled to meet heating and cooling loads during unoccupied hours.
9.4.2.3 Fan Power
a) For Systems Types A, B and D,
P fan = cmh × . 5 1
Where Pfan = Standard Design fan power in watts
cmh = Standard Design supply airflow rate auto-sized by the simulation software
b) For System Type C
Fan power shall be modeled as per power and efficiency limits specified in Table 5-12 using a static pressure of 622 Pa or the design static pressure, whichever is higher. The simulation software shall automatically calculate the Standard Design fan power based on the above inputs.
9.4.2.4 Design Airflow Rates
Design airflow rates for the Standard Design shall be sized based on a supply air to room air temperature difference of 1 1 ° C . The Proposed Design airflow rates shall be as per design.
9.4.2.5 Economizers (airside and waterside)
Airside economizers shall be modeled in the Standard Design as per the requirements of §5.3.3. Exception to §9.4.2.5: Airside economizer shall not be modeled for Standard Design HVAC System Type A.
9.4.2.6 Energy Recovery
Energy recovery shall be modeled in the Standard Design as per the requirements of §5.3.
9.4.2.7 Chilled Water Design Supply Temperatures
Chilled water design supply temperature shall be modeled at 6 . 7 ° C and return temperature at 1 3 . 3 ° C .
9.4.2.8Chillers
Only electric chillers shall be modeled in the Standard Design for System C. Chillers shall meet the minimum efficiency requirements indicated in Table 5-1 and Table 5-2. Chillers in the Standard Design shall be selected as per Table 9-3 below:
Table 9-3Modeling Requirements for Calculating Proposed and Standard Design
Peak Building Cooling Load (kWr)
Chiller Type
< 1,055
1 Water Cooled Screw Chiller
1,055 to 2,110
2 Water Cooled Screw Chillers
> 2,110
2 Water Cooled Centrifugal Chillers minimum, equally sized such that no Chiller is greater than 2,813 kWr
Exception to above: Air cooled chillers are allowed to be modeled in the Standard Design if the Proposed Design has air cooled chillers. If the proposed building has a mix of air and water cooled chillers, then the Standard Design shall be modeled with a mix of air and water cooled chillers in the same proportion as in the Proposed Design. However, this exception applies only for minimum ECBC compliance. Air cooled chillers shall not be modeled in the Standard Design when demonstrating compliance with ECBC+ and SuperECBC Building requirements.
9.4.2.9 Chilled Water Pumps
Chilled and condenser water pumps for the Standard Design shall be modeled as per power and efficiency limits specified in Table 5-15.
Standard Design chilled water pumps shall be modeled as primary-secondary with variable secondary flow.
9.4.2.10 Cooling Tower
Standard Design cooling tower shall be modeled as an open circuit axial flow tower with power and efficiency as per Table 5-18. The fans shall be modeled as two speed.
Condenser water design supply temperature shall be 2 9 . 4 ° C or 5 . 6 ° C approach to wet bulb temperature, whichever is lower, with a design temperature rise of 5 . 6 ° C ,
9.4.2.11 Boiler
Standard Design boilers shall be modeled as natural draft boilers and shall use the same fuel as the Proposed Design. Boiler efficiency shall be modeled as per Table 5-19.
9.4.2.12 Hot Water Design Supply Temperatures
Hot water design supply temperature shall be modeled at 8 2 ° C and return temperature at 5 4 ° C .
9.4.2.13 Hot Water Pumps
The Standard Design hot water pumps shall be modeled with a minimum efficiency of 70% and a pump power of 300 W / - s - 1
Standard Design hot water pumps shall be modeled as primary-secondary with variable secondary flow.
Notes: 1. Buildings of the listed occupancy types or spaces in Mixed-use Buildings with the listed occupancy types. 2. Where attributes make a building eligible for more than one system type; use the predominant condition to determine the Standard Design system type provided the non-predominant conditions apply to less than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for non-predominant conditions if those conditions apply to more than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for any space which has a substantial difference in peak loads and/ or operational hours compared to the predominant space type. Such spaces may include but are not limited to computer/ server rooms, retail areas in residential, or office buildings.
Notes: 1. Buildings of the listed occupancy types or spaces in Mixed-use Buildings with the listed occupancy types. 2. Where attributes make a building eligible for more than one system type; use the predominant condition to determine the Standard Design system type provided the non-predominant conditions apply to less than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for non-predominant conditions if those conditions apply to more than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for any space which has a substantial difference in peak loads and/ or operational hours compared to the predominant space type. Such spaces may include but are not limited to computer/ server rooms, retail areas in residential, or office buildings.
Notes: 1. Buildings of the listed occupancy types or spaces in Mixed-use Buildings with the listed occupancy types. 2. Where attributes make a building eligible for more than one system type; use the predominant condition to determine the Standard Design system type provided the non-predominant conditions apply to less than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for non-predominant conditions if those conditions apply to more than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for any space which has a substantial difference in peak loads and/ or operational hours compared to the predominant space type. Such spaces may include but are not limited to computer/ server rooms, retail areas in residential, or office buildings.
Notes: 1. Buildings of the listed occupancy types or spaces in Mixed-use Buildings with the listed occupancy types. 2. Where attributes make a building eligible for more than one system type; use the predominant condition to determine the Standard Design system type provided the non-predominant conditions apply to less than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for non-predominant conditions if those conditions apply to more than 1,000 m2 of conditioned floor area. Use additional system type for any space which has a substantial difference in peak loads and/ or operational hours compared to the predominant space type. Such spaces may include but are not limited to computer/ server rooms, retail areas in residential, or office buildings.