A Regulatory body (Urban/ Regional Planning & Development Regulatory Authority) at State level should be established to regulate and monitor the functioning of Urban and Regional Development Authorities/ Agencies. This regulatory body should assess and monitor planning, observe and evaluate impacts of planning, quicken the process of approval of plans in the States.
Plan evaluation after every five years must be built in as permanent process, and be mandatorily done at the completion of the planning period. The parameters for evaluation of plan must be predefined in the early stages so as to have a set of parameters as benchmarks towards the end of plan period. The basic parameters are provided in Table 2.4, besides these, other specific predefined plan related evaluation parameters could be added.
Table- 2.4: Parameters for the Evaluation of Plans
| S.No. | Evaluation Parameters | Quantitative benchmarks against the Plan to be evaluated |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Comparison with the projected population | Comparison of population projected and the present populationCarrying capacity of the developed area vis a vis per person land availability |
| 2 | Comparison of existing land use with the planned land use | Percentage deviation from the planned land use of the major and minor changes |
| 3 | Upward trend of economy | Contribution of sectors of economy in GDP of the city,Performance of individual sectors especially MSME,Performance of city GDP in comparison to State/National GDP,Workforce participation ratio,Workers classification,Income generation and participationFemale employment ratioVertical movement of the population from Below Poverty Line or lower income groups of the population |
| 4 | Funds invested | Percentage share of expenditure vis-a-vis the phase and/or project life budgetNumber of proposed projects completed |
| 5 | Achievements of targets in Infrastructure development | Comparison against benchmarks provided by National AgenciesChange in the ratio of infrastructure coverage |
| 6 | Direction of growth vs planned growth | Number of planned TP Schemes or Zones developedNumber of Non-Agricultural conversions |
The basic objective of the review/ evaluation would be to assess the progress and identify area of success, failure and conflicts to guide/correct the future course of action. This is an important step in the dynamic planning process, which hitherto has not been effectively utilised. This activity should be made mandatory under the respective T&CP Acts.
The following sections provide more details of various stages of this process.