The approach of planning should be shifted from top-down to bottom-up approach to make planning process more inclusive, comprehensive, and sustainable. Greater public acceptability is desirable, to ensure that plans are relevant. People can participate in the development process in the following realms:
■ Pre-plan participation in decision making in vision development, for identification of development priorities.
■ Post-plan participation before finalisation and implementation of development programmes and priorities.
■ Participation during implementation and evaluation of development programmes and project.
■ Participation and sharing the benefits of development, managing the assets etc.
e-Platform and crowd sourcing are coming up as new modes of obtaining feedback speedily.
Taking into account the interest, attitude and behaviour of the people, role of urban development professionals and obligations of local authority, a system of participatory plan approach has been suggested as under:
Table- 2.3: Participatory Planning Approach
| Planning Process Steps | Citizen's &Citizen Representative(s) | Urban development professional(s) | Official(s) |
| Determining goals and objectives | √ | 0 | √ |
| Data collection | √ | ||
| Design of criteria and standards | √ | ||
| Developing alternative plans | 0 | √ | |
| Choosing an alternative | √ | √0 | √ |
| Detailed design of selected plan | √ | ||
| Modification of plan | √ | 0 | √ |
| Plan Approval | 0 | √ | |
| Implementation | 0 | √ | √ |
| Monitoring | √/0 | √ | |
| Maintenance | √/0 | √ | |
| Feedback | √ | √ | √ |
| √= Major role, 0= Facilitating or supportive role | |||
Source: Community Planning Assistance Program, Arizona Department of Commerce and UDPFI Guidelines, 1996.
The suggested indirect participation of the people is ensured through elected representatives in the municipal council / corporation and ward committees. The direct participation can be through individuals, citizens, neighbourhood, business, consumer, and other such groups.
There are several mechanisms and avenues for people's participation available today, few of these have been presented below. Such mechanisms and avenues can be used to bring wider and more interactive participation of public in planning and developmental process²:
Community Design Charrettes i (see endnote): It is a multiple-day interactive meetings, workshops and site walks/visits that fosters diverse and community-sourced ideas;
Advisory Committees: Committees made up of representatives guide planning efforts over an extended period of time while regularly meeting during the planning process;
- Low-Cost Demonstrations and Transformations: Use of blocks and day to day objects to create a low cost model of proposals for visual understanding. Relatively inexpensive temporary transformations are made to test the project and experience changes.
■ Focus Groups: allow small groups of stakeholders to provide their knowledge of a project area and discuss their concerns and issues with local authority staff, planning consultants etc.
² Modification of - Participation Tools for Better Community Planning by Local Government Commission & The California Endowment
- Other: Citizens report card, participatory mapping and participatory budgeting etc.