Embodied energy is given less importance in the affluent regions of the world since their operating energy is high. There are two methods to evaluate this energy: by process or by input-output. Researchers in the Indian Institute of Science13 identified process analysis as appropriate for embodied energy assessment in the Indian context.
One of the earliest researchers using process-based analysis of embodied energy, Dr. Mohan Rai, carried out studies at CBRI Roorkee in the early 1960s and made the first listing of embodied energy, sorted in descending order, as follows:
| Materials | Unit | kWh(th) | MJ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheet Glass | sqm | 74.199 | 267.1 |
| Linoleum | sqm | 46.287 | 166.6 |
| Aluminium | kg | 39.891 | 143.6 |
| PVC | kg | 32.273 | 116.2 |
| Sanitaryware | kg | 9.071 | 32.7 |
| Mild Steel | kg | 7.327 | 26.4 |
| L.D. Polyethylene | kg | 6.048 | 21.8 |
| Stoneware Pipes | kg | 5.896 | 21.2 |
| Cement | kg | 2.245 | 8.1 |
| Quick Lime | kg | 1.756 | 6.3 |
| Bloated Clay Aggregate | kg | 1.477 | 5.3 |
| Burnt Clay Roofing Tiles | each | 1.233 | 4.4 |
| Burnt Clay Bricks | each | 1.187 | 4.3 |
| Wood Particle Board | kg | 0.861 | 3.1 |
| Sand Lime Bricks | each | 0.773 | 2.8 |
| Clay Fly-Ash Bricks | each | 0.643 | 2.3 |
| Gypsum (Calcined) | kg | 0.420 | 1.5 |
| Brick Dust (Surkhi) | kg | 0.384 | 1.4 |
| Crushed Aggregate | kg | 0.060 | 0.216 |
Embodied Energy
12 Accessed in December 2019 at https://www.slideshare.net/sslele456/embodied-energy-in-residential-cost-effective-units13 K.I. Praseeda, B.V. Venkatarama Reddy, Monto Mani, 2015. Embodied energy assessment of building materials in India using process and input–output analysis, Energy and Buildings, 86 (677-686), ISSN 0378-7788
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Embodied Energy
The table above shows (as is well-known) that the embodied energy of processed industrial materials like aluminium, steel and cement is much higher than relatively unprocessed and mined materials extracted from nature (like crushed aggregates). Natural and renewable materials such as timber may be deemed to have zero renewable energy. Therefore, all other things being equal, a concrete framed structure with cement and steel is worse than a load bearing structure with hardly any cement and steel and masonry (preferably non-fired) and funicular forms holding up the roof.
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Annex B-Best Construction Practice
B
Energy can be consumed in bad practices that may be observed on building sites. This needs to be stopped but is currently outside the scope of the ENS code. Typical practices include excessive requirement of movement of fluids (like mixed concrete) or solids (like steel) on site due to bad layout, improper sizing of pipes to save initial costs but causing greater pumping power due to friction losses, an over- or under-reliance on assisted manual labour (which may be seen as a form of renewable energy), and industry having got used to fuel-based services or energy-on-tap (firm energy) and so unable to convert to renewable energy such as solar photovoltaic systems (due to their being infirm, not available on-tap). Often machinery is also often designed so as to have very high starting surge loads, thereby making it impractical to invest in capital-intensive technologies (renewable) instead of fuel-based technologies, causing emissions and/or pollution. These areas need to be improved and then can be codified.
Although according to the study conducted by Jadavpur University14 98% of the embodied energy is attributed to the embodied energy of the materials used and 2% is the contribution of actual erection of the building, it is important to look at this seemingly trivial 2% for the main reason that there can be a lot of energy wasted and emissions and pollution created by bad site practices, and also because better site practices lead to better buildings and saves cost for the builder, thereby (ultimately) resulting in more affordable construction.
To achieve this:
Layout planning of sites should be made a course in civil engineering and project managers need to, by mandate, graduate in at least a one-semester course in this subject.
Civil engineers need to be able to engage with concepts of renewable energy through manual labour and solar and wind energy systems and they, along with project managers, need to, by mandate, graduate in at least a one-semester course in this subject.
Total energy losses due to waste and friction on site (per unit area of building being made) need to be analysed, benchmarked, and codified.
All these point to research directions that need to be undertaken (again by Civil Engineering departments in our Engineering Institutes).
Best industry standards for ratios of running energy: starting surge, need to be analysed, benchmarked, and codified, so that infirm energy sources such as solar photovoltaics may be able to be considered to meet the demand of energy on site. It may be noted that infirm energy sources such as solar photovoltaics could be seen to be a form of production of energy, and if managed well and with sufficient open area, with a good rental market created for solar photovoltaics or wind turbines, sites can in the future become energy-neutral for construction of buildings.
Since research in this area is nascent, it has been kept out of the ENS code for now.
14 Embodied Energy Analysis of Multi-storied Residential Buildings in Urban India, S Bardhan - WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, 2011
Best Construction Practice
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Retrofitting of Residential Buildings
Annex C- Retrofitting of Residential Buildings
C
Retrofitting consists of additions and alterations to existing (and, in the context of the ENS code, residential) building stock and typically this is set into motion by building owners.
For reasons of poor research and difficult practice, this code is currently silent on retrofit provisions and this appendix is created because given the right conditions this situation may change. This code does not mention provisions for retrofit cases because of the principle that laws (and codes) should preferably not be applied retroactively (so we cannot declare a building not meeting standards before the standard was even made), but in doing so we lose out a large potential of building stock (say over 50% of the residential building stock in 2030 if we read the McKenzie report15 that “nearly 70% of building stock that will be there in 2030 is yet to be built in India” and geometrically extrapolate it from 2010 when it was written to 2019 today).
The following market innovations need to be encouraged to cover a large part of India’s existing residential building stock even when they are not being added to or being altered:
For apartment dwellers, before enforcing this code, there need to be financial (lowinterest loan) instruments available or created whereby collective retrofitting may take place through collective action, for example changing of window or wall specifications through RWA action to comply with provisions of the ENS so that capital cost of such retrofits may be kept low per month.
For individual house owners, there need to be encouragement of vendors who can audit and retrofit because until that is done the implementation of ENS code shall be resisted or “loopholed” by homeowners.
For rental stock, these audit and retrofit companies can undertake audit and retrofit to meet the ENS code provisions either through RWA or through apartment owners’ associations (this is more difficult but can be eased by easy upgrade costs accompanied by strict compliance demands).
It would help a lot if the improvements effected by RWAs or contractors can be documented in a standardized way and the improvements in performance recorded numerically on a plaque or certificate for the owners to take pride in retrofitting their homes. This can be designed like the BEE star labels for various appliances.
It is anticipated that since the primary means of enforcing the ENS code is at the time of municipal approval and completion, this code could be immediately applied (subject to state-by-state acceptance into law) at the time of application for addition and alterations of buildings.
This would automatically exempt minor addition and alterations (such as raising internal walls, painting, etc.) For reference, these “minor” retrofits in existing buildings that do not need any permission according to Delhi Development Authority (DDA), similar to changes in buildings all over the country, are provided below:
India’s Urban Awakening: Building inclusive cities, sustaining economic growth (McKinsey Global Institute, April 2010)
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Excerpt from DDA16
-
To convert existing barsati into room provided the wall is made of only 115 mm thick.
-
Grills and glazing in verandah with proper fixing arrangement.
-
Raising height of front and rear courtyard wall upto 7’ height by putting up jali/ fencing.
-
Providing door in courtyard wherever not provided.
-
Providing sunshades on doors and windows wherever not provided with proper fixing arrangements.
-
Closing the door.
-
If the bathroom or WC are not having roof, these may be treated as open urinals and allowed.
-
Raising the wall of balcony/terrace parapet with grill or glazing upto 5’ height.
-
Construction of open staircase (cat ladder) where no staircase has been provided for approach to the terrace.
-
To put provide additional PVC water tank at ground floor area without disturbing the common passage.
-
To provide an additional PVC water tank in the scooter/car garage at the surface level.
12.. To provide loft /shelf in the rooms without chase in the walls.
-
To change the flooring with water proofing treatment.
-
To remove half (41/2) brick wall.
-
To make a ramp at front gate without disturbing the common passage /storm water drain.
-
To provide sunshades or the outer windows upto 2’wide projection.
-
To provide false ceiling in rooms.
-
To make an opening of maximum size of 2’6” x1’9” for exhaust fan or airconditioner in existing walls.
-
Fixing of door in back and front courtyard.
-
Converting of window into Almirah subject to availability of light and ventilation as per building byelaws provided that no structural elements are disturbed and there is no projection extending beyond the external wall.
-
Shifting of water storage tank/raising of parapet wall upto 5’ height and putting additional water storage tank. Wherever the existing water storage tank capacity is less than 500 ltrs in a flat, a 500 ltrs tank can either replace the existing water storage tank or if possible the additional tank can be added so as to make the total storage capacity upto 550 ltrs. However, such replacement/provision of additional tank will be done only on the locations specified for such tanks and the supporting beams will be required to be strengthened suitably. Parapet wall around terrace can be increased to a height of 5’.
-
To shift the front glazing, rooms/windows upto existing chajja.
6 http://www.dda.org.in/housing/pending\_cases/permissible\_alteration\_housing.htm, accessed December 2019.
Retrofitting of Residential Buildings
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Retrofitting of Residential Buildings
Not implementing retrofit cases for, say, 5 years, it can then be suggested that the ENS code could be made applicable to all Addition and Alterations cases that come for approval to ULBs. This will cover at least some 5% of existing building stock (say 10% of 50%) and simultaneously measures (1) through (3) in the last page need to be actively pursued in the market to make alterations proactively possible for existing building stock, even when not undertaking additions and alterations.
Generally, alterations in themselves do not require municipal approval. The key changes that require getting municipal approval is increase of height / FAR / Ground Coverage, all of these are related to increasing the size of the home.
Studying codes from other countries17, it can be seen that whenever a project comes up for municipal sanction, the codes require the renovated project to comply with the code provisions. This should be recommended in India also.
This will leave out only that part of the existing building stock that has a completion certificate from the ULB and remains unchanged. In time it shall be added to (requiring ULB approval) or demolished and rebuilt (requiring ULB approval). Therefore, by the later part of this century definitely the entire residential building stock shall become ENS compliant, even if market forces do not already make it so.
17 There are many references. See for instance, the Residential Compliance Manual for the 2019 Building Energy Efficiency Standards, California, at https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/2018publications/CEC-400-2018-017/CEC-400-2018-017-CMF.pdf, or https://www.buildwaikato.co.nz/building-projects/additions-alterations/ from the Waikato Building Consent Group (WBCG) in New Zealand, both accessed in December 2019.
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Annex D- Improved Air Cooling
D
Residential buildings sector accounts for 24% of the electricity consumption and is the second largest consumer after industries. Within the building sector, the residential electricity consumption amounts to 259 TWh. Within this sector, with increasing affluence in the Indian middle class, there is a tendency (in warm humid, hot dry, composite and even moderate climates which always have some hot days) to create comfort by installing an air-conditioner or two. Capital costs of air conditioning is low compared to capital costs of building (today, cheap – and inefficient – air-conditioning can be as low as 5% of the building cost). EMI-based loans make it easy for even a lower middle-class family to install split air-conditioners at less than the monthly energy costs of running the same.
Use of air-conditioning therefore is a major hurdle in creating energy efficient residential stock in India, since it cannot be denied that it creates superior comfort in all sorts of conditions: warm humid, hot dry, composite, and moderate.
Often the rationale for a lower middle-class family, who realize that the energy bills are not easy to manage, is that they will use it minimally, only in the night and only in extreme weather, or by setting the thermostat up to higher temperatures. However, air-conditioning, with its superior performance in terms of managing humidity, is addictive, and there is a tendency for its use to increase to the limit of the users’ paying capacity, and even beyond it.
It is worse that in this economic class, the tendency is to procure cheap, lower rated inefficient equipment, and install it in poorly insulated houses, which uses even more electricity than it could.
This causes residential air-conditioning to become a major barrier in energy efficiency (USAID, 2014)18. This issue is a major guzzler of energy in houses and needs to be mitigated by codification. However, since the research on this is ongoing, this has not yet been included in the ENS code.
On November 15, 2019, the Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI) in collaboration with the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) of the Government of India (GoI) announced the results of a Global Cooling Prize competition, for Incentivizing the development of a residential cooling solution that will have at least five times less climate impact than standard residential/room air conditioners (RAC) units in the market today. This technology could prevent up to 100 gigatons (GT) of CO2-equivalent emissions by 2050, and put the world on a pathway to mitigate up to 0.5˚C of global warming by 2100, all while enhancing living standards for people in developing countries around the globe19.
Therefore, the following are urgently required to be researched and implemented for Indian residences to become comfortable while remaining energy efficient, at capital costs that are affordable or can be made affordable by fiscal incentives or financial instruments:
Air-conditioning systems that can be used at higher set-point temperatures (say, up to 28 °C) in combination with ceiling fans. These require higher cfm of air to be pushed through (rather than the industry standard of 400 cfm per Ton) and a balance between refrigerant temperature, air flow, and set point since currently air-conditioning industry
Improved Air Cooling
18 HVAC Market Assessment and Transformation Approach for India, PACE-D Technical Assistance Program, USAID, August 2014
19 https://globalcoolingprize.org/ accessed in December 2019
Bureau of Energy Efficiency
Improved Air Cooling
has optimised all systems for 2 2 ° C - 2 4 ° C . As the set point temperature is increased, the other parameters need to change. This kind of device will be ideal for billconscious lower middle classes even if they can progressively afford air-conditioning capex.
Fiscal incentives or financial instruments to lower capex for improving house thermal performance to ENS code levels so that optimum (not too much) air-conditioning is installed. Unfortunately, at this point, the ENS code has been developed assuming that the cooling system is some form of air-conditioning.
Rapid development and deployment of effective an acceptable intermediate technologies including adiabatic technologies, such as passive hybrid and active evaporative coolers, better natural ventilation, indirect evaporative coolers, or chilled coil indirect evaporative coolers, combined with fiscal incentives or financial instruments to lower capex for improving houses to a level so that sufficient passive cooling is managed and the number of days of usage of cooling or conditioning can be brought down.
Alternative desiccant and evaporative systems for cooling (which are not yet welldeveloped). This may require fundamental research and cannot be expected to be rapidly deployed.
Promotion of all these above alternatives through some cultural or social incentives (such as the BEE star rating system or TV promotions) so that they are not perceived as inferior to “complete” air-conditioning. This requires a major social change in attitude from progress seen as consumption only to progress seen as sufficiency, but is probably the most effective instrument for meeting and even bettering the EPI targets of the ENS code.